By Christopher Aust
I was rather amazed at the number of people who wrote to me about my
opinions regarding the Humane Society of the United States (HSUS)
when I did my last few articles. Then again, maybe I shouldn't be.
Before about two weeks ago, I myself was rather ignorant as to the real
goals of HSUS, and where their, (actually your) money goes. As I always
do though, I decided to edumacate myself about them.
I also conducted a poll of 100 average people. Just the average Joe in
the street. 94% of the people thought HSUS ran the local shelters in
their community. 4% knew about their other programs and the remaining
2% had no idea who they were. Of the 94% all said they would donate to
HSUS based on what they knew about them. I'm betting HSUS is banking,
literally, on these types of individuals.
I also went online and found some rather interesting, at times quite
scary, information on several web sites. I would have interviewed a
HSUS representative, but after last week's newsletter, I got an email
from one that was little more than hate mail and very offensive!
Coleman Burke, then president of the American Bible Society, Cleveland
Amory and Helen Jones, founded HSUS in 1954. As far as I have been
able to tell, Mr. Burke served as their President until 1970 when John
Hoyt, a Presbyterian minister, took over as President and CEO until
Until just a few months ago, the President and CEO was Paul Irwin, a
Methodist minister. The current CEO and President is Wayne Pacelle who
admittedly has had ties with some radical (and I mean radical) animal
rights groups in the past.
Now, is it important I mention the religious background? Maybe and
maybe not. What I noticed though is the organization, at least to me,
has an evangelical feel. Is this a bad thing? No. I don't see why
unless you are running the finances in a manner similar to Jim and
Tammie Faye Baker! That sure is the way it looks to me.
Officers and Directors
HSUS is an organization with their primary focus being animals. As I
reviewed the names and titles of the Board Officers and Directors, I
found it curious they had no DVM's (vets) on either. They have three
MDs', three PhDs' and six attorneys. Am I the only one that finds this
odd? Plenty of lawyers, but no vet. Hmmmâ€¦Maybe it's just a typo.
Comparative Financial Operations Report
When I conducted my interview with Kathy Bauch a few weeks ago, she
refused to answer any questions regarding HSUS' finances for a
"newsletter." She did offer to send me their 2003 financials though.
This is what they send whenever some one has questions about their
finances. As I mentioned last week, if it was similar to what they have
online, it would be vague and difficult to decipher. What I got was
What I received is their 2003 Annual Report. It is a twenty-one page
"report" that wasobviously very expensive to print. Tucked way in the
back is exactly what I expected. A vague and difficult to read one page
financial report. The rest appears to me to be a very expensive sales
letter and nothing more, complete with a postage paid envelope to send
in your donation.
Now you might say, "So what? They have to promote themselves." I
agree. However, this publication has six pages of calendar quality
photos of nothing but animals. Two and a half pages of self-glorifying
articles from HSUS staff, none of which was necessary. How much donor
money could have been saved by deleting this junk from the thousands
and thousands of these reports they printed?
According to the Comparative Financial Operations Report for 2003, the
HSUS has $116,205,882.00 in total liability and net assets. Over
$5,000,000 of that is in cash and cash equivalents, and another nearly
five and a half million in receivables. They also have nearly
$93,000,000 in market value investments. Not too bad.
In 2003, in revenue, additions and transfers, HSUS made $76,923,670.
Of that amount, sheltering programs received $10,551,527 and it was
shared with animal habitat and wildlife programs. Now, assuming it was
an even split, sheltering programs received $3,517,175.66
Now that's a lot of money, but not when you consider a good sized
shelter can cost hundreds of thousands of dollars a year to run, three
million is really a drop in the bucket. They spent $21,145,769.00 in
fundraising and membership development. Six times what they put into
their shelter programs, which is what most people I talked to think
HSUS does with the money donated to them.
Providing Help or Selling It
I'm not sure what they spent the money on for their shelter programs,
but I will assure you they didn't fund any shelters. In fact, they
charge shelters and Animal Control offices for their assistance and
instructional material. I have been able to find little and or nothing
HSUS doesn't charge for when it comes to helping a shelter and their
For instance, lets say you or your town runs an animal shelter that is
struggling for one reason or another, which most are, HSUS is ready to
come in and help. For between $4000.00 and $20,000.00 they will send
their experts to your shelter through their Animal Services
Consultation Program. The fee depends on the size of the agency and the
complexity of its programs, charged on a sliding scale based on your
agency's resources. In other words, the more you have, the more they'll
Now, lets go back to our youth. You're in middle or high school and
want to start a club to promote rescue and do things to help companion
animals. HSUS can help you with that, too. Just go to humaneteen.org.
There you can buy a package full of all kinds of propaganda and learn
to be a full-fledged animal activist. They will sell your child a club
starter kit for $22.00 and then give activity suggestions like their
"Fight Fur" program.
Here they encourage kids to make flyers and hand them out in front of
businesses to protest against shoppers buying fur. HSUS will also give
your child cards to distribute at such events. They'll show your child
pictures of dead animals in traps and direct them to other sites where
they can see pictures of hunters beating seals over the head.
They will also promote vegen/vegetarian lifestyles to your child. Just
go to the message board for kids and you can read how many of the kids
are distressed, after reading the material HSUS SOLD them, because
their parents will not let them go vegen. You will also see posts
Now I want to be fair here. They do have some decent material that is
age appropriate and educational in nature. I think it's overpriced; for
instance, your child can rent a video to show their class for $25.00,
but some of it is good material. However, there is little promoting
appropriate training, grooming or responsible ownership of companion
animals. It seems to me the whole focus is turning our children into
activists, vegens and extremists.
Now if I want my child to be a vegen, or an activist, I will make that
decision and not HSUS. Our kids have enough on their plate without
having to be weighed down with this information or agenda.
Additionally, kids are kids and don't always make appropriate
decisions. When dealing with complex issues like activism and
protesting, it would be easy for them to get into trouble or hurt.
Doesn't PETA target children too?
Ethical Financial Practices
Let's get back to the money: Former President John Hoyt once instructed
his members on becoming more humane: "We begin, I suggest, by living
more simply, more sparingly." Let's see how he did. He made around
$200,000.00 in the late 1980's running HSUS. In 1986, HSUS bought his
house in Maryland for $310,000 and allowed him and his family to live
there, free of rent, until 1992. When he retired as CEO, HSUS gave him
a $1,000,000.00 bonus.Paul Irwin, another former President, while
making $300,000.00 from HSUS, was given an $85,000.00 interest free
loan to renovate his cabin in Maine. The cabin was held in trust by
HSUS, however his family continued to use it until he died. This is
just the tip of the iceberg. Makes me wonder.
Guilty by Association
Let's look at some of HSUS' associations: In April of 2000 HSUS sent
J.P. Goodwin as its emissary on an anti-fur mission to China. Goodwin
is not just any animal rights zealot, he was an avowed member of Animal
Liberation Front (ALF), a group once called one of the biggest domestic
terrorist organizations by the FBI. He had been convicted for vandalism
of several fur retailers and their property. Less than a year later, he
was formerly identified as a HSUS legislative staff member.
If you don't know about ALF you should check them out. They truly scare
the heck out of me. They are, in my opinion, every bit as much a threat
to people as Al Quiada. I cannot believe HSUS would hire such a person.
When asked questions about an arson fire at a slaughter house in
Petaluma, California, and a Utah feed co-op that nearly killed a
family, Goodwin stated, "We're ecstatic!"
Then, there is the PETA connection ...
HSUS has repeatedly hired PETA employees in their organization. Their
head of investigations, several investigators, a computer programmer,
just to name a few. Sorry folks, my opinion is, once a terrorist,
always a terrorist. When HSUS hires these people, they appear to
support the crimes these individuals may have been involved in.
In 2003, HSUS VP Martin Stephens was asked to recommend three
people to serve on an EPA "pollution prevention and toxics" panel. Two
of his three choices were PETA employees.
All Talk and No Action
While HSUS will admit they don't run or fund any shelters, you usually
find it at the bottom of the page or tucked away somewhere near the end
of a statement. As I mentioned before, they don't put their money where
their mouth is. Get this â€¦
In 1995, when the Washington DC animal shelter was going to have to
close due to a budget shortfall, HSUS (based in DC) offered to build
and operate a DC shelter at its own expense to serve as a national
model. There were, of course, conditions.
HSUS wanted the city to give it 3-5 acres of land and tax exempt status
for all of its real estate holdings in the District of Columbia.
(Remember, they buy some executives homes to live in among other
property holdings.) The DC government offered a long-term lease but
HSUS refused to proceed unless it would "own absolutely" the land. The
district declined, and the only HSUS funded animal shelter never
HSUS, who makes and has enough money to fund a shelter in every state,
as well as subsidize spay/neuter programs, declined to help the dogs in
its own back yard. Why? Money is all I can think of. Perhaps they were
afraid they would soil their Armani suits by actually working with a
The New CEO
Rather than go on a tirade about the new President and CEO of HSUS, I
have put some quotes from him below. Read them, and you decide.
"I think they wanted the aggressive approach," he says. "They wanted
someone who was going to think things up. And they got him." June
2004, Washington Post when asked about his selection as CEO.
"We have no problem with the extinction of domestic animals. They are
creations of human selective breeding." Quoted in Animal People, May,
I could go on for days about HSUS, but I will stop here. In my opinion,
they are little more than an organization whose main agenda is filling
the coffers and pushing an extremist agenda through misinformation and
exploitation. Again, my opinion, they have done nothing but profit from
the contributions of people who don't know any better. I have tried to
see it otherwise, I simply can't.
I highly recommend you go to activistcash.com and see what they have
there about HSUS and their connection with PETA. There are several
other sites I found interesting, as well as many stories about HSUS in
the archive of the Washington Post.
Would I give anything to the Humane Society of the United States? Yes I
would. A pooper-scooper, they can use to go clean my yard. At least
then we would know they actually have done something for a dog this
This article may be republished using the following attribution box:
Copyright Â©2004 Christopher Aust, Master Dog Trainer & Creator:
The Natural Cooperative Training System (NCTS) for Dogs
The Instinctual Development System (IDS) for Puppies
Subscribe to the BARK 'n' SCRATCH Newsletter: subscribe@Master-Dog-
VISIT NOW: http://www.Master-Dog-Training.com